It’s as Easy as 1… 2… 3…
Book and Evaluate
Stop by or give us a call at 920-395-2442 to book an evaluation of your items.
Display and Sell
We’ll sell your quality items in our professional retail environment.
Sit Back, Get Paid
Login to our consignor portal and watch the money roll in. Ka’ching!
CONSIGNMENT QUICK INFO
Fall/Winter 2026 Consignment Appointments Are Full
Our Fall/Winter 2026 consignment appointments are now completely booked. We understand it can be disappointing to miss the booking window, and we truly appreciate the incredible interest in consigning with Nikki’s Nex2New!
Upcoming Booking Dates
Spring/Summer 2027: Appointments will open for booking after December 1, 2026.
Fall/Winter 2027: Appointments will open for booking after July 4, 2027.
Our appointments typically fill within approximately two months of opening, sometimes sooner. We encourage you to schedule early for the best selection of appointment dates.
Current consignors: If you have an upcoming appointment during an open booking period, you may schedule your next seasonal appointment while you are in the store.
As consignment continues to grow in popularity, our appointment calendar fills very quickly. We offer approximately 2,500 appointments each season and schedule on a first-come, first-served basis. While we do our best to accommodate as many consignors as possible, we can only accept a limited number of appointments each day.
Walk-In Consignment Events
We accept certain seasonal items without an appointment on designated dates.
Please watch our website and social media for updated 2027 dates and requirements.
Prom Dresses: Prom consignment is accepted starting December 1st; get them in early! We will stop accepting on Feb 28th.
Homecoming Dresses: Typically accepted during the summer. Dresses must be junior sizing, short/formal styles, purchased within the last 2–3 years, clean and freshly laundered or dry cleaned, and free of rips, tears, or excessive wear. All zippers, hooks, and buttons must be attached and functional.
Winter Coats, Snowpants & Winter Boots: Accepted Sept 1-Oct 31. Coats should be no more than 2–3 years old and must be freshly cleaned before being brought in. We accept winter coats only—no fleece or lightweight spring jackets. Winter boots should be clean with little to no visible wear. Fashion boots are not included in this walk-in event.
Halloween: Accepted during our designated fall dates. Costumes must be clean and complete with all pieces included.
Christmas: We accept seasonal Christmas clothing, including ugly Christmas sweaters, children’s holiday dresses, and other Christmas items, during designated dates.
Preparing for Your Appointment: We are very selective when choosing consignment items. Please carefully inspect your items before your appointment.
Items should be current, clean, in excellent condition, and ready to go directly onto the sales floor. If items appear not to have been reviewed before being brought in, we reserve the right to end the appointment and return the items.
Nikki’s Nex2New customers have come to expect stylish items in nearly-new condition. Please remember that our selections are based on business needs, current inventory, customer demand, and historical shopping trends—not personal preference.
Consignors, please read below:
Missed Appointment Policy: If you no-call/no-show for a scheduled appointment, you may be unable to schedule another appointment for up to one year. We will consider your appointment history and the size of the missed appointment.
A missed appointment fee will also be charged to your account when an appointment is missed without cancellation notice, Single appointment: $10, Double appointment: $20, Triple or larger appointment: $30 etc
Appointment Reminder Texts: If you receive an appointment reminder text, please reply YES to confirm you will attend. Please note: We cannot respond to messages sent to the appointment reminder number. To cancel, change, or reschedule an appointment, please call us directly at 920-395-2442.
How to Schedule: When the appropriate booking window is open, appointments may be scheduled by: Calling: 920-395-2442 or In person: 804 N 8th Street, Sheboygan, WI 53083
We will be happy to help determine the appropriate appointment size based on the number and type of items you have.
We do not schedule consignment appointments through email, Facebook, Instagram or text messages.
Important:
MyResaleWeb is no longer active. Please use our current consignor account link provided on our website.
If you need an access code or assistance accessing your account, please call 920-395-2442, and we will be happy to help.
Booking Schedule
Spring/Summer 2027:
Appointments will open for booking after December 1, 2026.
Fall/Winter 2027:
Appointments will open for booking after July 4, 2027.
We will be happy to set up a custom-sized appointment for you! Please note that we do not schedule appointments via email, Facebook, Instagram, or text.
Nikki’s Nex2New Makes Consignment a Breeze!